Skip to content
Technology News

T-Mobile illegally imposed 50 GB cap on low-income home internet plan NY says

New York state officials have reached a settlement with T-Mobile following an extensive investigation that found the wireless carrier in violation of the New York Affordable Broadband Act (ABA). The state alleged that T-Mobile systematically restricted the quality and accessibility of home internet services mandated for low-income residents, effectively undermining the legislative intent of a law designed to bridge the digital divide. Under the terms of the agreement, T-Mobile is required to eliminate data caps and speed throttling on these specific plans, expand geographic availability, and improve transparency regarding how eligible customers can enroll.

The investigation, spearheaded by the Office of the Attorney General (OAG) and supported by Governor Kathy Hochul, centered on T-Mobile’s fixed wireless home internet service. While the company marketed these services to the general public, it was also legally obligated to provide affordable, high-speed options to income-eligible households. Instead, authorities found that the company imposed a 50 GB monthly data cap, after which download speeds were throttled from a functional 25 Mbps to a near-unusable 600 Kbps.

A Legislative Battleground: The Affordable Broadband Act

The enforcement action follows a tumultuous four-year legal struggle between the State of New York and the telecommunications industry. The Affordable Broadband Act, which mandates that internet service providers (ISPs) with at least 20,000 customers offer high-speed home internet at $15 per month for 25 Mbps speeds or $20 per month for 200 Mbps, was fiercely contested by industry lobby groups.

Major industry associations, including CTIA—the trade organization representing major wireless carriers like T-Mobile—challenged the statute in federal court, arguing that state-level price regulations were preempted by federal authority. The legal battle persisted until December 2024, when the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear an appeal from the industry, effectively clearing the path for full implementation in January 2025.

Despite the industry’s loss in the highest court, the subsequent investigation into T-Mobile suggests that the transition to compliance was fraught with administrative obstacles. New York officials discovered that even after the law took effect, T-Mobile had implemented internal policies that effectively discouraged enrollment and limited the utility of the service for those who needed it most.

T-Mobile illegally imposed 50 GB cap on low-income home Internet plan, NY says

Chronology of the Regulatory Conflict

The timeline of the dispute highlights the friction between state mandates and corporate operational policies.

  • 2021–2024: The broadband industry engages in a protracted legal challenge to strike down the New York Affordable Broadband Act.
  • December 2024: The Supreme Court rejects the industry’s final challenge, cementing the legality of the $15 broadband mandate.
  • January 2025: New York officially begins full enforcement of the ABA.
  • June 2025: The New York Department of Public Service alerts the Attorney General’s office to potential non-compliance regarding T-Mobile’s low-income plan features.
  • Late 2025 – 2026: A state-led investigation confirms that T-Mobile’s service for low-income users was significantly inferior to standard plans, including data caps and artificial speed throttling.
  • November 2026: A formal settlement is reached, compelling T-Mobile to bring its plans into compliance within a 120-day window.

Technical Limitations and Intentional Obfuscation

Perhaps the most damaging findings of the Attorney General’s investigation involved the deliberate technical barriers T-Mobile placed in front of low-income applicants. According to the settlement documents, T-Mobile restricted the availability of the ABA plans exclusively to areas where it had already deployed 5G infrastructure. This created a geographical exclusion for thousands of residents in rural or semi-urban areas where the company offered 4G LTE home internet, even though those same 4G networks were perfectly capable of delivering the mandated 25 Mbps speeds.

Furthermore, investigators found evidence of digital "redlining" on the company’s own website. T-Mobile had allegedly applied a "noindex" tag to the specific webpage detailing the ABA plans. This technical maneuver prevented search engines like Google from indexing the page, ensuring that prospective customers searching for "affordable internet in New York" would be unable to find information about the state-mandated low-cost options. By hiding the information, T-Mobile effectively limited the program’s uptake, a practice that state officials characterized as a clear violation of the spirit and letter of the law.

The Impact of Data Throttling

The 50 GB data cap identified by the state was identified as a critical failure point. In modern households, 50 GB of data is a modest allotment. For a family utilizing the internet for remote schooling, telehealth appointments, or basic streaming services, this limit could be reached in as little as four days. Once the cap was hit, the drop from 25 Mbps to 600 Kbps effectively rendered the connection useless for anything other than basic text-based browsing, preventing participation in the modern digital economy.

The settlement requires T-Mobile to remove these caps entirely for the low-income plans. Furthermore, the company is now prohibited from using "noindex" tags on its affordable broadband landing pages and is required to place prominent links to these plans on its main residential home internet product pages.

T-Mobile’s Response and Corporate Context

In a formal statement, T-Mobile did not explicitly admit to the violations detailed in the settlement but committed to working with the state to rectify the service issues. "We have a long history of helping customers in New York stay connected through low-cost broadband, and we’re updating our plan to meet the state’s requirements while maintaining the same low price," the company stated.

T-Mobile illegally imposed 50 GB cap on low-income home Internet plan, NY says

This settlement follows a separate, high-profile agreement between T-Mobile and the New York Attorney General’s office just last month regarding the company’s "Price Guarantee." In that instance, the state investigated T-Mobile for violating a "lifetime price lock" guarantee it had marketed to customers, only to raise rates by $5 per line in 2024. That settlement provided approximately $38 million in estimated value to affected consumers through various reimbursement options and extended price protection until 2029.

Broader Implications for Broadband Policy

The T-Mobile settlement serves as a warning to other ISPs operating in New York. The Attorney General’s office has signaled that it will be vigilant in ensuring that the Affordable Broadband Act is not treated as a suggestion. The threat of lawsuits, which can include civil penalties of up to $1,000 per violation and demands for restitution, remains a potent deterrent.

However, the future of such state-level enforcement remains politically contentious. The incoming federal administration has indicated a desire to preempt state-level broadband regulations, particularly those that conflict with federal goals for the $42 billion Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program. While states like California and New York are currently pushing back, asserting their right to protect local consumers through price regulation and net neutrality laws, the legal landscape remains volatile.

For the residents of New York, the outcome of this investigation is a significant victory for consumer access. By forcing a major carrier to dismantle artificial barriers to connectivity, the state has reaffirmed that in an era where high-speed internet is a necessity for work, education, and government services, private corporations cannot unilaterally determine the standards for low-income access. As T-Mobile moves to update its network offerings within the 120-day compliance window, the state will continue to monitor the company’s infrastructure, ensuring that the promise of affordable, high-speed broadband becomes a reality for all eligible New Yorkers.

Iffa Jayyana
Written by

Iffa Jayyana

Journalist and staff writer covering the technology and future shaping our world.

Blog News Tweets
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.