Skip to content
Technology News

The Pseudoscience of Race Realism and the Modern Resurgence of Hereditarian Ideologies

The recent intensification of political rhetoric linking national origin and racial identity to inherent cognitive ability has sparked a renewed debate among scientists and sociologists regarding the boundaries of academic freedom and the legitimacy of race science. During the World Economic Forum in Davos, former US President Donald Trump characterized individuals from Somalia as possessing low IQs, a claim that mirrored earlier statements by Donald Trump Jr. regarding Haitian migrants. These assertions, which echo the tenets of "race realism," represent a significant shift in public discourse, bringing fringe academic theories into the mainstream political arena. While proponents of these views argue they are engaging in legitimate, albeit controversial, scientific inquiry, the broader scientific community—particularly in genetics, evolutionary biology, and anthropology—has consistently categorized these claims as pseudoscientific, noting that they rely on methodologically flawed data and antiquated biological concepts.

A Chronology of the Modern Resurgence

The re-emergence of racialized intellectual narratives did not occur in a vacuum. Throughout the post-World War II era, the scientific consensus had largely moved away from biological determinism, following the rejection of eugenics after the atrocities of the Nazi regime. However, a small network of academics and institutional backers has worked to maintain the viability of these theories.

In the 1960s, the publication Mankind Quarterly emerged as a central venue for proponents of hereditarianism, heavily supported by the Pioneer Fund. Founded in the 1930s by textile magnate Wickliffe Draper, the fund was explicitly intended to support research into racial differences and to provide intellectual ammunition for segregationist policies. Throughout the 20th century, this network sustained itself through private funding and dedicated academic silos. In recent years, these efforts have migrated into the digital age, utilizing platforms like Aporia Magazine and social media channels to reach broader audiences, often bypassing traditional peer-review mechanisms by establishing their own fringe journals or infiltrating specific subfields of psychology.

Scientific Foundations and Genetic Reality

The core of the "race realist" argument is the "hereditarian" hypothesis: the belief that genetic factors are the primary determinants of behavioral and intellectual differences between racial groups. Modern genomics, however, provides a contradictory picture.

“Race realism” isn’t realistic—and it isn’t good science

In the 1970s, evolutionary biologist Richard Lewontin established the foundational principle that there is significantly more genetic variation within any given human population than there is between populations. Contemporary advances in ancient DNA analysis have further dismantled the notion of "pure" ancestral bloodlines. Archaeological evidence confirms that human history is defined by constant migration, intermixing, and adaptation. Genetic markers for physical traits like skin pigmentation or lactose tolerance are not neatly mapped to the social categories of "race." Instead, these traits are highly localized adaptations to specific environmental pressures, such as ultraviolet radiation levels or dietary shifts, and are found across diverse populations globally.

When researchers examine the human genome, they find that race is a poor proxy for biological or genetic information. Claims that evolution produced distinct, intellectually hierarchical "races" ignore the complex, polygenic nature of intelligence and the overwhelming evidence of environmental influence.

The Failure of the "National IQ" Database

A critical pillar of the race science community is the "national IQ" database—a collection of statistics frequently cited to suggest that average cognitive ability is lower in developing nations, particularly those in sub-Saharan Africa. Statisticians and social scientists have thoroughly debunked these datasets for methodological malpractice.

The fundamental flaw in these databases is the conflation of IQ scores with innate intelligence. IQ tests are heavily influenced by access to formal education, nutrition, socioeconomic stability, and familiarity with test-taking formats. The "Flynn Effect," a well-documented phenomenon where IQ scores have risen globally throughout the 20th century, serves as a primary refutation of hereditarian claims. Because this rise occurred over mere decades—far too rapidly for evolutionary genetic change—the increase must be attributed to environmental factors, such as improvements in public health, education, and nutrition. Consequently, researchers have pointed out that "national IQ" studies often select skewed samples, deliberately using data from impoverished or marginalized groups to artificially depress the averages for specific countries or racial populations.

Institutional Challenges and Academic Gatekeeping

The persistence of race science in academic journals is a point of significant contention. While prestigious journals in biology and genetics have largely purged these theories due to their failure to meet rigorous standards, specific subfields—particularly evolutionary psychology and certain branches of intelligence research—have remained vulnerable.

“Race realism” isn’t realistic—and it isn’t good science

Editors of journals such as Intelligence have occasionally defended the publication of controversial papers by invoking the need for "robust academic debate." Critics, however, argue that this is a misuse of the concept of academic freedom. They contend that academic freedom is intended to protect the pursuit of truth through rigorous, replicable methodology, not to provide a platform for pseudoscientific narratives that have already been falsified by the scientific community.

Recent years have seen some institutional pushback. When it was revealed that secret conferences on eugenics were being held at University College London, the institution launched an investigation and took steps to terminate the events. Similarly, after investigations by groups like Hope Not Hate revealed the secret funding of race science networks by tech figures such as Andrew Conru, several entities withdrew their support or funding. Despite this, figures like Nathan Cofnas have managed to retain academic affiliations, even while drawing intense criticism for their calls for a "hereditarian revolution."

Broader Implications for Society

The implications of these academic debates extend far beyond university hallways. When political leaders adopt the language of race science, it creates a feedback loop that justifies discriminatory policy. If social disadvantage is perceived as an inherent, biological trait of a specific group rather than a product of structural inequality, the ethical imperative to address poverty, systemic racism, or lack of opportunity is weakened.

The historical trajectory of this rhetoric is grim. Eugenics-based policies in the 20th century, ranging from forced sterilization in the United States to the genocidal campaigns of the Third Reich, were built on the same foundations of biological determinism currently being revived. Today’s proponents often argue that they are simply following the data, yet their work consistently ignores the vast, multidisciplinary consensus of the modern behavioral sciences.

Conclusion: The Necessity of Rigor

The scientific community maintains that the "race realist" approach is not a realistic view of human diversity. Rather than representing a suppressed truth, it functions as a ideological project that misuses the language of science to promote predetermined social and political agendas. As technology allows for a deeper understanding of human biology, the gap between the complex reality of human genetics and the simplistic, rigid categories of race science continues to widen. For the public and for policymakers, the challenge lies in distinguishing between valid scientific exploration and the promotion of narratives that have been repeatedly debunked by the very disciplines they claim to represent. Moving forward, the academic community faces the ongoing responsibility of maintaining strict standards for what constitutes evidence, ensuring that the reputation of scientific inquiry is not undermined by the persistence of 19th-century racial hierarchies masked in modern terminology.

Muslim
Written by

Muslim

Journalist and staff writer covering the technology and future shaping our world.

Blog News Tweets
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.