Skip to content
Affiliate Marketing

California and New York’s New Synthetic Performer Laws

As artificial intelligence continues to blur the line between reality and digital fabrication, the states of California and New York have taken decisive legislative action to mandate transparency in advertising. The emergence of hyper-realistic digital avatars—commonly referred to as "synthetic performers"—has prompted regulators to address potential consumer deception. With the rapid proliferation of generative AI tools capable of cloning voices and creating photorealistic human likenesses, these new legal frameworks serve as a critical checkpoint for advertisers, media agencies, and technology platforms seeking to utilize AI in commercial content.

The Rise of Synthetic Media in Advertising

The integration of synthetic performers into marketing campaigns is not merely a technical novelty; it is a burgeoning industry trend. Global investment in generative AI is projected to reach unprecedented heights by 2030, with a significant portion of this growth concentrated in the creative and media sectors. According to industry analysis, synthetic media allows for the rapid localization of campaigns, enabling brands to produce multilingual advertisements with a single digital model, thereby reducing production costs and increasing efficiency.

However, the ease with which these assets can be created has outpaced existing consumer protection standards. Until recently, traditional truth-in-advertising laws, such as those enforced by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), were primarily designed to combat deceptive claims about products or services. The specific challenge posed by AI—the creation of a human persona that does not exist—falls into a legal gray area that both New York and California are now moving to clarify.

Chronology of Legislative Action

The regulatory landscape began to shift as public awareness of "deepfakes" and AI-driven impersonation grew. New York was the first to formalize requirements for the disclosure of synthetic performers in commercial advertising. The state’s legislative efforts were largely motivated by the need to ensure that consumers could differentiate between authentic human endorsements and computer-generated simulations.

California followed suit with the passage of SB-1050, a more granular and comprehensive piece of legislation. While New York’s law has already been implemented, California’s statute is set to become fully effective on January 1, 2027. This timeline gives advertisers and creative agencies a window to audit their current inventory and update their compliance protocols to meet the more rigorous standards set forth by the California legislature.

Key Regulatory Divergences

While both states share the common goal of transparency, the mechanisms by which they achieve this goal vary significantly, creating a complex compliance landscape for national brands.

One of the most notable distinctions lies in the definition of a "synthetic performer." New York’s statute broadly captures AI-generated and computer-generated figures, providing a wide net that covers various forms of digital animation. In contrast, California’s SB-1050 is specifically tailored to AI-generated entities. Furthermore, the California law expands its scope to include audio-only advertisements, addressing the rise of AI-cloned voices in radio and podcast advertising—a medium where New York’s current mandate is notably silent.

The definition of "conspicuous disclosure" also presents a challenge. New York requires advertisers to make their disclosures "conspicuous," a term that is subject to interpretation and judicial precedent. California, however, provides a more prescriptive framework, defining the term as "difficult to miss." By providing sample disclosure language, California is attempting to reduce the ambiguity that often leads to litigation, yet this rigor also increases the burden on advertisers to ensure their compliance is documented and visually or auditorily distinct.

The Threshold of Prominence

A critical differentiator in the California law is the concept of "prominence." SB-1050 does not apply to every minor use of a synthetic figure. Instead, it triggers disclosure requirements only when the synthetic performer is used in a prominent capacity. The statute provides a specific taxonomy for what constitutes "prominent" use:

  • The performer is in the foreground and is demonstrating or illustrating a product or service.
  • The performer is providing the primary narration or voice-over for the commercial message.
  • The performer is reacting to the on-camera narrative, effectively serving as an active participant in the advertisement’s storyline.

New York’s regulatory approach is broader and does not distinguish based on the prominence of the performer. Consequently, under New York law, even a secondary or background synthetic character may trigger a disclosure requirement, depending on the specific interpretation of the governing authorities.

Knowledge Requirements and Liability

Liability thresholds vary between the two jurisdictions, which is a major concern for national ad agencies and third-party marketers. New York’s law generally requires "actual knowledge" of the use of a synthetic performer for liability to attach. This offers a degree of protection for agencies that might inadvertently use a synthetic asset provided by a client or an external content creator without being fully aware of its nature.

California’s framework is significantly more stringent. It does not contain an explicit "actual knowledge" requirement, meaning that the burden of verification rests squarely on the advertiser. If a campaign incorporates a synthetic performer, the advertiser is liable for the failure to disclose, regardless of whether they were aware that the asset was AI-generated. This creates an immediate need for robust internal vetting processes, especially when working with third-party vendors, as an agency’s negligence could result in significant legal exposure for the brand.

Economic and Legal Implications

The financial consequences of non-compliance highlight the seriousness of these mandates. In New York, violations carry a specific penalty structure: $1,000 for the first violation and $5,000 for each subsequent violation. While these figures may seem modest for large-scale campaigns, they can aggregate quickly if an advertisement runs across multiple platforms for an extended period.

California’s approach is fundamentally different. It does not set a flat fine; instead, it incorporates violations into the state’s existing framework for false advertising and unfair competition. This means that a breach of the synthetic performer disclosure law could expose an advertiser to class-action litigation and significant civil penalties that far exceed the fixed fines found in New York. The potential for such litigation makes California the primary jurisdiction of concern for national advertisers, as the "unfair competition" designation provides a powerful tool for consumer advocacy groups and state regulators alike.

Impact on the Advertising Ecosystem

Industry experts suggest that these laws will force a structural shift in how creative assets are managed. Brands will likely implement "AI-provenance" tracking, ensuring that every digital asset used in a campaign is clearly labeled at the source. This could lead to a new standard in metadata tagging for advertising assets, where the presence of synthetic media is embedded directly into the file properties.

Furthermore, these laws are expected to influence the development of generative AI tools themselves. Software companies may begin to integrate automated disclosure features into their platforms, ensuring that any video or audio output that meets the legal definition of a synthetic performer includes a mandatory disclaimer by default.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

As these laws take hold, the advertising industry must prepare for a future defined by radical transparency. The era of the "unmarked synthetic" is coming to an end. For legal and marketing teams, the immediate priority is to conduct a thorough audit of all ongoing and upcoming campaigns to ensure that any AI-generated likenesses or voices are appropriately disclosed.

While New York and California are currently at the forefront, it is highly probable that other states will adopt similar legislation, eventually leading to a patchwork of regulations that may prompt federal intervention. For now, the takeaway is clear: the integration of AI in marketing is no longer a Wild West scenario. It is a regulated discipline that requires careful legal consideration and a commitment to consumer clarity. Companies that prioritize transparency today will not only avoid the costs of litigation but will also build greater trust with a public that is increasingly wary of the digital content they consume.

Richard B. Newman is an advertising practices attorney at Hinch Newman LLP. This article is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

Nana Wu
Written by

Nana Wu

Journalist and staff writer covering the technology and future shaping our world.

Blog News Tweets
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.